In recent years, there has been an increasing focus on diversity, equity, and inclusion in the workplace. Following the introduction of gender pay gap reporting in 2017, the UK government has now turned its attention to ethnicity pay gap reporting. While ethnicity pay gap reporting is not currently mandatory, the government has published guidance to help employers who choose to voluntarily report on their ethnicity pay gaps.
In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the background and considerations of ethnicity pay gap reporting, the key aspects of the new guidance, and the potential challenges and benefits for employers. Let’s dive in!
Background to Ethnicity Pay Gap Reporting
Gender pay gap reporting has played a crucial role in raising awareness about gender disparities in the workplace. It has prompted companies to examine the underlying causes of pay gaps and take action to reduce them. Following the success of gender pay gap reporting, the UK government recognized the need to address ethnicity pay gaps.
However, ethnicity pay gap reporting presents unique challenges compared to gender pay gap reporting. Understanding the different outcomes for various ethnic groups, the lack of ethnicity data, and the significant variations in ethnic diversity across different regions all contribute to the complexity of ethnicity pay gap reporting. Consequently, the government has chosen not to make ethnicity pay gap reporting mandatory but has provided voluntary guidance for employers who wish to report on their ethnicity pay gaps.
The Ethnicity Pay Gap Reporting Guidance
The new ethnicity pay gap reporting guidance aims to standardize the methodology and approach to ethnicity pay reporting. It covers five main topics that employers should consider when reporting their ethnicity pay gaps: collecting employees’ ethnicity data, gathering payroll data for calculations, making ethnicity pay calculations, analyzing the results, and developing action plans to address any disparities.
To ensure consistency with gender pay gap reporting, the guidance recommends employers calculate the mean and median ethnicity pay gaps, mean and median bonus gaps, the proportion of each ethnic group receiving a bonus, and the proportion of each ethnic group within pay quartiles. Additionally, employers should report the representation of ethnic groups across the organization as a whole and the percentage of employees who did not disclose their ethnicity.
Collecting and Classifying Ethnicity Data
Collecting accurate and meaningful ethnicity data is a crucial first step in ethnicity pay gap reporting. The guidance suggests using the harmonized standards for collecting ethnicity data, which include questions from the most recent censuses in England & Wales and Scotland. It is important to note that ethnicity is considered special category personal data under the UK General Data Protection Regulation, and employers must handle the data sensitively and in compliance with data protection laws.
Employers should strive for granularity in their ethnicity data collection to ensure a more accurate understanding of pay gaps. While the guidance recommends reporting gaps by all 17 ethnicity groups, it acknowledges that smaller employers may face challenges in achieving this level of detail. In such cases, employers can group employees into broader categories, such as white, black, Asian, mixed, and other. However, it is important to recognize that even within these broad categories, there can be differences in pay gaps among specific ethnicities.
Addressing Small Groups and Statistical Robustness
Ethnicity pay gap reporting may encounter challenges when dealing with small groups of employees, particularly in regions with low ethnic diversity. The guidance suggests setting a minimum category size for analysis to ensure statistical robustness and protect the confidentiality of individuals. For internal reporting, a minimum category size of 5 to 20 employees is recommended. For external reporting, a minimum category size of 50 employees is advised.
The impact of these thresholds varies across different regions in the UK. In areas with high ethnic diversity, employers with a relatively small number of employees may meet the minimum category size. However, in regions with low ethnic diversity, larger employers may be required to meet the threshold. Employers should aim to strike a balance between statistical robustness and the need for meaningful analysis.
Beyond Binary Analysis: A Granular Approach
The guidance strongly discourages reporting a binary pay gap analysis that combines all ethnic minorities into a single group. Instead, employers are encouraged to take a more granular approach to ethnicity pay gap reporting wherever possible. This allows for a deeper understanding of the nuances and specific disparities among different ethnic groups.
Ideally, employers should report pay gaps for all 17 ethnicity groups. However, the reality is that this level of detail may not be feasible for all employers, especially those with smaller workforces. In such cases, grouping employees into broader categories can provide some insight, but it is important to recognize that this approach may mask differences between specific ethnicities within each group.
Dealing with Incomplete Datasets and Data Protection
Incomplete datasets can pose challenges in accurately measuring and analyzing ethnicity pay gaps. The guidance emphasizes the importance of ensuring a sufficient participation rate to obtain robust statistics. Employers should encourage employees to disclose their ethnicity information, update privacy notices, and communicate effectively to build trust and improve participation rates.
Processing employee personal data revealing racial or ethnic origin is subject to additional protection under the UK GDPR. Employers must identify a lawful basis (Article 6) and a special category condition (Article 9) for processing such data. The guidance highlights that employers should undertake a data protection impact assessment (DPIA) and have appropriate policies in place to comply with data protection laws.
Taking Action on Ethnicity Pay Gaps
Ethnicity pay gap reporting is not an end in itself but a means to identify disparities and take action. Employers are encouraged to provide a supporting narrative that explains the pay figures, analyzes the reasons for disparities, and provides wider workforce statistics to provide a clearer picture. Employers may consider publishing an action plan with measurable targets to address specific issues identified as causes of unfair pay gaps.
It is crucial to note that the challenges faced by different ethnic groups may vary, and employers must tailor their narratives and action plans accordingly. The government is launching an Inclusion at Work panel to develop advice on evidence-based actions that employers can take. This panel’s work will inform a voluntary Inclusion Confident Scheme, which employers can join to demonstrate their commitment to promoting diversity and inclusion.
The Future of Ethnicity Pay Gap Reporting
While ethnicity pay gap reporting is currently voluntary, there have been calls for mandatory reporting from various quarters. The government’s decision to provide guidance indicates its recognition of the importance of addressing ethnicity pay gaps and promoting transparency. Employers should stay informed about potential legislative changes and consider the benefits of voluntarily reporting their ethnicity pay gaps.
In conclusion, ethnicity pay gap reporting presents unique challenges and opportunities for employers in the UK. By following the government’s guidance, collecting accurate and meaningful data, and taking appropriate action, employers can contribute to creating a fairer and more inclusive workplace. While the journey towards achieving equity and equality is ongoing, ethnicity pay gap reporting is a step in the right direction.
[/et_pb_text][/et_pb_column][/et_pb_row][/et_pb_section]
